I think the more fundamental question we need to ask ourselves is: Is the reality we perceive nothing more than "signals" impinging on biological sensors and producing a "model" inside the neurons of our brains (themselves part of this same reality) - and is there any way to show that these signals are coming from a "true" reality that exists outside "us" or are we all just one gigantic programmed simulation? That the so-called "Big Bang" was nothing more than the computer being turned on?
That all of the forces of gravity, electromagnetism, etc are in truth, nothing more than functions of a fundamental operating system, and that there are innumerable programs just like this one running in parallel?
In a scenario like that, both the Atheist and any other form of Theist, or Spiritualist, etc, would all be right in a sense. Whoever turned on the the "main computer" or programmed it, or built it, would be "God" yet no direct evidence of their existence would be found unless they put it in the program - but that also implies that they could put anything into the program.
It also means they can "pause" the program anytime and we would not know or even be able to tell it happened.
The strangeness of the quantum gives us a hint that something weird is going on, because of the fact that at those scales things are not "defined" sharply anymore. Things don't behave in any fashion like they do at our everyday scales. It's almost if we got down close the "bits"
But on the other end, at the level of the cosmos, again things are not behaving properly. Galaxies are moving too "slow" so we posit this invisible "dark matter" to explain it, and dark energy to explain why the observable universe is expanding too fast. Maybe, the processor needs an upgrade? it cant run fast enough at those scales?
Edited by SteampunkScientist, 21 December 2018 - 08:05 AM.