Paradox
©
Fisana

Jump to content


Photo
* * * * * 1 votes

Natalensis vs Cubensis - a few notes from the mycelial interwebz


  • Please log in to reply
11 replies to this topic

#1 Samwise

Samwise

    Mycophage

  • OG VIP
  • 170 posts

Posted 03 January 2023 - 04:42 PM

In case it might be of use or interest to fellow psilonauts, sharing some testimonials concerning cultivation and perceived potency and qualitative differences between P. natalensis and P. cubensis mushrooms sourced from the mycelial interwebz, having scanned a few forums (such as the Shroomery and Mycotopia) and various Reddit groups. I did this while doing some research because I was unable to track down a single article on the web on Natalensis (or much information on it of any kind really). Due to the lack of available information, sharing this in case it might inspire interest or be useful to people. I feel this is important information to share, particularly for beginner mushroom growers, as this is widely reported to be a more forgiving and tenacious species to grow (with more aggressive mycelium that can eat through moulds potentially, unlike Cubensis), while also generally being preferred for the experience it provides. As I'm sure some mycotopians are already aware, it can be grown in the same way as Cubensis, with some growers stating that it prefers a little more fresh air exchange during fruiting. It is widely reported as being more potent than your average Cubensis while being smoother on the body, with less body load and an easier come-up, and yielding a cleaner/clearer headspace that is often reported as being friendlier and more positive or uplifting in comparison to Cubensis. My intention here is not to slate Cubensis...I'm hugely grateful for this mushroom and some of my most amazing experiences have resulted from ingesting it. But still there is more to the psilocybin mushroom world than it alone, and Natalensis seems like a species worthy of more attention.

 
These accounts in no way suggest that ingesting Natalensis mushrooms make one bulletproof when it comes to bad trips or anything like that, and I appreciate these accounts may come across as cherry-picking. I haven't read the gargantuan 375-page thread on the Shroomery linked below in its entirety, and this would be worth delving into if you want to find out more, as it likely includes negative experiences too which may provide some balance.
 
Please feel free to add your own views based on your experiences growing or sampling this species in response to this post.
 
Summary taken from a Shroomery thread on P. natalensis:
 
Psilocybe natalensis:
 
- Are stronger than most Cubensis, on average.
- Grow with same teks and substrates as Cubensis.
- Grow fast.
- Have super aggressive, unstoppable mycelium that uses contam as food.
- Sometimes overlay, but you can pick that off and make it into active tea.
- Fewer bad trips than Cubensis.
- Different trip than Cubensis, some folks like it more. Maybe "friendlier" trip is a better term.
 
 
Cultivation:
 
"I wouldn't be surprised if Natalensis becomes the most common cultivated species within the next 5-10 years, lots of cloning/isolates needed to dial in specific phenos but yeah, IMHO it's far superior."
 
"Natalensis ticks all the boxes, from cultivation to the experience they offer."
 
"My favourite strain, my culture is stupidly fast and aggressive and hella potent."
 
"It grows under the very same conditions as Cube varieties do, only much more aggressive. So it's actually easier to grow than Cubes."
 
"Natalensis are as easy to grow as Cubensis but stronger and seem to be a happier experience for most."
 
"Treat them the same as Cubensis."
 
"Treat just like cubes. Super aggressive mycelium."
 
"Natalensis are like Cubensis, but grow some really vigorous mycelium."
 
"They’re a great trip and a nice alternative to growing Cubensis with pretty much the same process. They need more FAE (fresh air exchange) but will manage with standard Cubensis process."
 
"They require a little more fae than cubes but not much else different."
 
"You can pretty much treat them exactly like cubensis. They do like a little more fresh air."
 
"P. natalensis will grow easily and aggressively. Needs 5x more air [than Cubensis]."
 
"I do think nats like just a little more fresh air than most cubes do."
 
"They need a shit ton of FAE, a lot more than cubes."
 
"Q: Any more difficult than Cubensis to grow? A: Not at all, used the same process/tek as Cubensis. I was worried with all the information I was coming across on whether cvg would take or not, worked out just fine."
 
"Natalensis are pretty hardy and this was only 210g wet first flush. They are a little quicker than Cubensis but yield less. I’ve been getting 3 decent flushes so total yield isn’t much different."
 
"Growing these guys is definitely fun tho and the extremely aggressive behavior of the myc might be much better for new growers."
 
"They do seem more resistant to contams than cubes. They appear to respond with super aggressive growth and overlay to any contams."
 
"I think this species is so close to wild yet that a lot of work cloning/isolating yet to be done but hoping soon they will be the go to for new cultivators as it's such a forgiving species, I've seen the mycelium clouds literally eat trich and bacteria and shit out flushes in response."
 
"Here is another example of how tough Natalensis is. …it got some funk [mould] on it. Despite that, the mycelium colonised the rest of the jar and is starting to work on the bad section."
 
"The mycelium of this strain is crazy hungry, and extremely resistant to contamination. If you see mold growing, it will soon be consumed."
 
"Super aggressive mycelium that's so fast it's contam resistant almost like oysters."
 
"I love how aggressive the mycelium is. It marches through what seems to be contaminated grain like an unstoppable juggernaut."
 
"They are fast growers, very strong against contams."
 
"Natalensis grow fast and rhizo and resist most contams IME, but they often overlay like crazy."
 
"My culture does eat through Trichoderma [mould], or at least I’ve seen it happen with this culture on two tubs. My other tubs didn’t contaminate visually if at all but a couple got a green spot, next day completely dusted green, thought it was dead but left it with the lid locked for four days and I came back to check it and it had pinned. 1oz dry flush too, no fruit damage."
 
"Natalensis are so fun and forgiving. I think one of my jars has (had) mould but it looks like it might be eating it up."
 
"I just grew a few bags, I did 16 different strains, I have very positive reviews on the P. natalensis - they finished 3 flushes before the other strains could do the first flush."
 
"Your next grow should be Psilocybe natalensis. Not much more difficult than Cubensis to grow. But they will take you out of this universe."
 
"I feel like Nats are the new, next gen easy-to-grow cultivation mushroom, and there is so much research to be done."
 
"If these aren't Cubensis, and they consistently behave as this thread suggests, they may just become the new Cubensis."
 
 
Potency:
 
"They’re usually around 1.5x potency of Cubensis."
 
"They are about 1.5x as potent as a standard Cubensis I’d say."
 
"Natalensis are more like 1.5 times as potent as Cubensis."
 
"Psilocybe natalensis are 1.5-2x more potent and average cubes, less mental fuck and more blissful."
 
"Natalensis are about double the potency on average compared to Cubensis."
 
"They are about double the potency on average compated to cubes."
 
"They are close to 2x stronger than most cubes."
 
"About twice as strong [as Cubensis] with a nicer come up."
 
"They are super strong though like 2x the strength of cubes."
 
"The natalensis I've had were 2-3x stronger than regular cubensis.  Although that could just be personal sensitivity or an unusually potent variety."
 
"Tried Natalensis out for the 1st time last night. A 2.3g tea fried me! Totally taken by surprise how strong these were. Thought I peaked then an hour later - got slammed hard. I'd put these right up there with APE [Cubensis]."
 
"It was very very obvious that 2 grams of Natalensis felt like 5 grams Cubensis. My reality was shattered. I began to question my career and intentions. Trip is very “loopy” and visually stimulating. Will potentially kick your ass."
 
"…it's a different species then Cubensis. They are much stronger too."
 
"I’d say they are potent like a TaT or ape [Cubensis] strain, definitely stronger than a golden teacher."
 
"Natalensis are super strong just warning you lol it felt like I took almost 5g [of Cubensis] but I took 2.6g."
 
"My experience was very profound on just 1.5g via tea; definitely stronger than cubes at the same dose, but extremely gentle, as many have stated."
 
"Last night I took Natalensis. 1.5g knocked me out of this world. It came on very quickly (about 30min) and then kept intensifying for about 3 more hours."
 
"Natalensis are about twice as potent as Cubensis but the body load is still there."
 
"South African here, I recently grew P. Natalensis and tripped last Friday... WOW. A friend and I wanted to give these guys a try – so we each took 1.8g, expecting a light buzz and maybe some mild visuals. To keep a long story short, the come up was at most 10 minutes, and the 1.8g was the strongest, most intense trip I’ve experienced by a lightyear – far exceeding my previous maximum dose which was 8g of P. Cubensis."
 
"I suggest starting at 1g to test potency, 2-3 grams people reporting DMT like OBE already."
 
 
Qualitative effects:
 
"Finally tried 2 grams. Never eating cubes again. Freakin amazing. Cubes just don't mix well with me, bad body load on the come-up it is always uncomfortable. Large doses of cubes also just made me so fucked I didn’t really remember much. But damn these are so smooth and clean."
 
"They are usually on par with PE. So around 2x but the trip is superior to cubes. They are more visual, highly euphoric and zero body load. I stopped taking cube’s because they made me bloated and miserable. Nats are really clean feeling. Even high doses are wonderful."
 
"Don’t want to make a super long post but this HAS to be said. I’ve tried a few different types of shrooms, and many different types of cubes. But I can wholeheartedly say, without a shadow of a doubt, that Natalensis is the best of the best. Incredibly strong and visual, but with such a “clean” headspace. I could hardly believe it was only mushrooms, felt like I was hippieflipping in a way. Guys, please try some nats."
 
"These are hands down the best strain I ever have tried...haven't tried pans yet but these grow super fast and easy. Deff more therapeutic/healing/spiritual for me...cubes give me a crazy body load and I feel more on edge it's weird af."
 
"P. Natalensis hands down... the headspace is so uplifting and enjoyable where cubes have tendency to get weird and heavy introspective shit..."
 
"I personally won't dose high with cubes cause they're scary as shit but nats are so much nicer."
 
"I tend to be happier on Nats. They seem less edgy to me [than Cubensis]."
 
"Cubes have an edge and a dark side that make me wary. But Nats are kinder to me. I did get paranoid one time on a higher dose but it was much more manageable than with cubes."
 
"The experience is also very unique. Really hard to beat, and can make cubes seem harsh and synthetic in way, when compared."
 
"Gotta say I don’t really have any interest in cubes anymore, they never had me laughing and having that much fun as natalensis."
 
"Will never eat another regular cube again after eating these lol love to grow them as well."
 
"Yeah definitely do feel way more healing and therapeutic [than Cubensis] for sure! I definitely feel way better for days after unlike cubes. Just overall better experience from start to finish and the days after are all noticeably better."
 
"They are a superior trip to cubensis for sure. Stronger than most cubes, very euphoric, and very little body load. I’ve done high doses with them and feel like I could have doubled my dose and just had more fun lol."
 
"After Natalensis, I'll rarely touch a Cubensis again save for microdosing."
 
"I've tried some other strains since making this first post, but still had the best experiences with Natalensis."
 
“Currently my new favorite the only way I can describe it is it feels cleaner I don't get any preflight anxiety...I wouldn't say their a whole lot more potent definitely stronger but it's a much clearer headspace for me love em.”
 
"These are a great trip. Little to no body load, very visual, and extremely euphoric."
 
"They do IME have a different trip than Cubensis too. I find them to have little body load, great visuals, and very euphoric. Very nice trip."
 
"They are amazing, fairly certain there's compounds present that aren't in ps cubensis, they are noticeably different both in the headspace and visuals."
 
"I can only compare them to APE [Cubensis], and I prefer these. I guess you could say they're about equal in strength, but they give me a whole different level of trip. If cubes are 3D, Natalensis are 4D."
 
"Like 3g of Amazonians or GT's [Cubensis] vs 3g Natalensis strength wise the Natalensis is more potent but not by much (IMPO) but the trips are different, that much is for sure...put it this way this strain is in many growers top 5."
 
"It was such a clean feeling trip too. Minimal nausea. Smooth come up. They’re a 10/10 for me and I probably won’t grow anything else for a while."
 
"They have the most gentle come up, no nausea at all for me. And they are very strong. It's a much more intense trip than Cubensis. And longer lasting."
 
"Cultivators are describing Natalensis to be as potent as Penis Envy Cubensis while offering a qualitatively superior experience to P. cubensis."
 
"The trip is definitely a bit different. Better come up and down. Also feel overall on general that lasts longer."
 
"Come up and down was super smooth. Overall trip felt longer than cubes. No come up anxiety either."
 
"In my experience they have a pronounced empathogenic like headspace and overall sedating feel to them, also no thought loops like cubes. They are all around better for me. Definitely a different compound profile."
 
"Can confirm these are cube killers! I will also most likely not dose cubes for an experience again. The come up is strong, but so clean! And to put clean into words I mean there is ZERO body load that you find with regular cubes. No stomach aching, no weird uncomfortable state between sober-peak, it just shoots you off in about 20-30 minutes."
 
"I just tried P. natalensis for the first time recently, the South African cousin species to cubensis. The trip was actually rather different from cubes, for me at least. It felt more mellow in the head, but the body load was euphoric and lovely. If P. natalensis is an available option (it is growing in popularity, largely because you can grow it exactly like cubes) I highly recommend it."
 
"A friend imported Natalensis spores from Africa, and he says hands down his favourites to grow and eat. They have a different vibe, he says."
 
"Nah I won’t say twice as strong [as Cubensis] although it is a hard hitter once it comes on, uncontrollable euphoric giggles at the most random shit, personally a unique experience that I personally feel is characteristic of this strain."
 
"Less nauseous [than Cubensis], and more clear. … Head space is clearer, sometimes I feel a little confused on Cubensis, wandering around the house not sure what I was going to do next."
 
"Natalensis is more crystal clear [than Cubensis], hard to explain."
 
"Natalensis always has a little sparkle to the trip, can't explain it, but we like them."
 
"They are more like MDMA and not so confusing for me compared to cubes."
 
"My new favorite for sure, any body load ya do get from them, is a good one."
 
"I tried out the Natalensis last weekend. 3.18g and holy shit. It was extremely intense and strange. The visuals were more of a light show quality than the normal crawling swirling. Almost like everything was lit by moving neon light."
 
"These were the most uplifting, less anxious, most friendly mushrooms I have ever taken and for those who are yet to try them, I highly encourage you do so. I am in love."
 
 
Commonly reported qualitative differences vs Cubensis:
 
- Smoother experience with an easier come up
- Less body load and nausea issues
- Cleaner/clearer headspace
- Friendlier and more uplifting and positive headspace, more prone to euphoria
- Distinct/superior visuals

Edited by Samwise, 03 January 2023 - 04:54 PM.

  • TVCasualty, Juthro, Severian and 1 other like this

#2 Seeker2be

Seeker2be

    Seeking Lost Horizons

  • OG VIP
  • 1,397 posts

Donator


Awards Bar:

Posted 03 January 2023 - 10:30 PM

what to do about the overlay? Rake it?



#3 YoshiTrainer

YoshiTrainer

    Onion tied to belt

  • Gold VIP
  • 1,893 posts

Awards Bar:

Posted 04 January 2023 - 04:19 PM

Usually it'll grow mushrooms through the overlay. The overlay is active as well.

Very nice write up Samwise, thank you for taking the time to compose this!
  • Samwise likes this

#4 Severian

Severian

    Mycotopiate

  • VIP
  • 598 posts

Awards Bar:

Posted 05 January 2023 - 07:42 PM

As a relatively new grower, with experience growing only cubensis, this is super helpful info. Now only to find a culture!
  • Samwise likes this

#5 TVCasualty

TVCasualty

    Embrace Your Damage

  • Moderator
  • 15,122 posts

Awards Bar:

Posted 06 January 2023 - 10:11 PM

Well I'm convinced to check them out.

 

One thing that occurred to me as I read through the mini trip reports and reviews is that many of the things they said about them and how they are better than cubes is exactly how I describe cubes taken with the lemon/lime juice pre soak.

 

I would bet that the qualitative difference between cubes and species that people report being more pleasant than cubes is due to something in the cubes that the other species lack, and the low pH soak can neutralize it.

 

 

But the more aggressive mycelium and greater resistance to contamination (apparently) makes it worth looking into even if it feels exactly the same as cubes, so thanks for the head's up!



#6 Samwise

Samwise

    Mycophage

  • OG VIP
  • 170 posts

Posted 07 January 2023 - 08:01 AM

Well I'm convinced to check them out.

 

One thing that occurred to me as I read through the mini trip reports and reviews is that many of the things they said about them and how they are better than cubes is exactly how I describe cubes taken with the lemon/lime juice pre soak.

 

I would bet that the qualitative difference between cubes and species that people report being more pleasant than cubes is due to something in the cubes that the other species lack, and the low pH soak can neutralize it.

 

 

But the more aggressive mycelium and greater resistance to contamination (apparently) makes it worth looking into even if it feels exactly the same as cubes, so thanks for the head's up!

 

Hey TVCasualty,

 

I hear you, I suspect part of the body load issues associated with Cubensis is the volume of fungal matter one must ingest to get to a certain level which can be hard on one's gut (compared to more potent species), and/or other compounds in the fungus that are eliminated when preparing a tea or lemon/lime juice pre soak as you mention. However it is interesting to note that there a numerous accounts of Natalensis experiences where people report a notable empathogenic headspace, describing it has being more prone to euphoria, and a few different people compared it to MDMA. So while it is possible there may be other compounds in Cubensis that may modulate the experience to some degree that Natalensis lacks, it is also possible that Natalensis may harbour secondary compounds that may modulate the experience to some degree that Cubensis lacks.

 

And yeah I agree, I think the more aggressive and contamination resistant mycelium alone warrants this species receiving more attention from growers (particularly beginner growers), irrespective of any potential differences in qualitative effects or potency.


Edited by Samwise, 07 January 2023 - 08:02 AM.

  • Juthro likes this

#7 Juthro

Juthro

    dope smoking hillbilly

  • OG VIP
  • 10,397 posts

Donator


Awards Bar:

Posted 07 January 2023 - 01:47 PM

It all sounds very appealing, especially for beginner growers or folks like me that just want a small batch now and again without investing a lot of resources or effort.  Doing PF style grows is mostly fool proof, but if there was an even more consistent option for success I would definitely try it.

 

Forgive me if I missed it in the above posts, but does anyone know where prints or spore syringes of Natalensis can be acquired?

 

This was a very nice write up, Samwise, thank you for the effort and the share.


  • Samwise and Mycol like this

#8 ItBeBasidia

ItBeBasidia

    Mycotopiate

  • VIP
  • 358 posts

Awards Bar:

Posted 07 January 2023 - 07:11 PM

As to the aggressive mycelium, I can attest to that. . It's scary how vigorous and aggressive the myc is. It does this sort of gnarly rhizomorphic "reaching" as it searches for more food that i haven't seen any other species invitro do. At least not to the magnitude of natalensis.752eb0fa7f0f3baf5c6f9040f2f7307d.jpg
  • TVCasualty, Samwise, Moonless and 2 others like this

#9 Severian

Severian

    Mycotopiate

  • VIP
  • 598 posts

Awards Bar:

Posted 08 January 2023 - 03:29 PM

Damn Yu ain't lying that is mega aggressive

#10 Juthro

Juthro

    dope smoking hillbilly

  • OG VIP
  • 10,397 posts

Donator


Awards Bar:

Posted 08 January 2023 - 03:48 PM

I am totally going to have to give these a try!  The thought of a more aggressive, and easier to grow (not that cube's are hard to grow) mushroom is very appealing.  I am also totally down with having a stronger mushroom that doesn't require as much in the way of weight to get me where I want to go.  With cubes I pretty much only do tea anymore to avoid ingesting a large amount of fruit bodies and the GI distress that comes with that. 

 

Not sure how these hadn't shown up on my radar until now.  I guess it is partly because I just got comfortable in doing what I've always done.... Anyway, thanks for showing me something new.

 

I'm looking forward to trying these, and that's a nice feeling. I really haven't been excited to grow any mushrooms in quite a while. It kind of just turned into a chore, like pressure canning beans, or harvesting from the garden.

 

Now I just have to find where I put my stash of grow bags.....:)

 

 


  • Samwise likes this

#11 Samwise

Samwise

    Mycophage

  • OG VIP
  • 170 posts

Posted 15 January 2023 - 06:24 AM

I am totally going to have to give these a try!  The thought of a more aggressive, and easier to grow (not that cube's are hard to grow) mushroom is very appealing.  I am also totally down with having a stronger mushroom that doesn't require as much in the way of weight to get me where I want to go.  With cubes I pretty much only do tea anymore to avoid ingesting a large amount of fruit bodies and the GI distress that comes with that. 

 

Not sure how these hadn't shown up on my radar until now.  I guess it is partly because I just got comfortable in doing what I've always done.... Anyway, thanks for showing me something new.

 

I'm looking forward to trying these, and that's a nice feeling. I really haven't been excited to grow any mushrooms in quite a while. It kind of just turned into a chore, like pressure canning beans, or harvesting from the garden.

 

Now I just have to find where I put my stash of grow bags.....:)

 

Hi Juthro, I hear you, my thoughts exactly - Natalensis has reinvigorated my growing game too, definitely a species worthy of having on one's radar I think. I'm just about to inoculate a load of grain jars/bags with LC, and looking forward to sampling these a little later down the line.


  • Juthro likes this

#12 Juthro

Juthro

    dope smoking hillbilly

  • OG VIP
  • 10,397 posts

Donator


Awards Bar:

Posted 15 January 2023 - 12:40 PM

I look forward to your report on it's effects, Samwise. I'm already sold enough that I am going to order a spore syringe as soon as I'm sure it won't freeze and break in my mailbox, as our our high temp yesterday was 3*F). 

 

I thank you again for your write up, and for bringing this to my attention.... 

 

Peace to you brother :)


  • Samwise likes this




Like Mycotopia? Become a member today!